The VerdictWhen I Work is a popular scheduler, but mid-sized teams evaluating it head-to-head with ClockIt consistently pick ClockIt for two reasons: a much cleaner, faster day-to-day UI and Kai—our built-in AI HR assistant that answers attendance, overtime, and scheduling questions in plain English. Plus, ClockIt never paywalls your scheduling look-ahead horizon or GPS geofencing.
No credit card required · Free plan available
See exactly what you get (and what you don't)
| Feature | When I Work (Free) | When I Work (Pro) | ClockIt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kai AI HR Assistant (Plain-English Queries) | No | No | Included on All Plans |
| UI & Day-to-Day Usability | Cluttered Multi-Add-On UI | Cluttered Multi-Add-On UI | Clean, Unified Schedule + Time Clock |
| Scheduling Horizon | Limited (often 10 days) | Unlimited | Unlimited on All Plans |
| GPS Geofencing & Biometric Terminals | No | Paid Add-On (No Biometric Hardware) | Included (+ Native ZKTeco Sync) |
| Job/Task Costing | No | Yes | Included |
It's not just about features. It's about the fundamental "value gap" in how we handle your time and money.
In head-to-head trials, operations and payroll teams tell us ClockIt is simply easier to navigate than When I Work and Sling. Schedules, live punches, overtime rules, and PTO live in one clean workspace.
Instead of clicking through five filters to see who was late or who is approaching overtime, just ask Kai AI in plain English ('Who worked overtime this week?', 'Who clocked in late today?') and get an instant answer.
Features like planning next month's schedule, preventing early clock-ins, or enforcing GPS geofences cost extra on When I Work. ClockIt includes every feature for $2.99/user/month.
Our Free Migration Concierge imports your employees, shift templates, and PTO balances so your team can go live without missing a single shift.
"We were moving away from Sling and compared ClockIt side-by-side with When I Work for our 85-person team. ClockIt was our clear winner—the UI and usability are much better, and the Kai AI features put it ahead."
Yes, we support easy data imports via CSV to get your team set up on ClockIt in minutes.
Yes. Employees can request cover or trade shifts directly from the mobile app, subject to manager approval.
ClockIt offers a fully functional 14-day free trial so you can test every feature without restriction before deciding.